Over Your Dead Body (2026) Movie Review: A Strong Third Act Redeems An Uneven, Albeit Consistently Entertaining Marital Dark Comedy

Share it

“Over Your Dead Body” is a creative union of unlikely partners. While based on a sadistic Norwegian dark comedy film from Timmy Wirkola (who has had his own breakthrough with English-language projects), the remake is also directed by the Lonely Island’s Jorma Taccone, and produced by 87North (the production company behind “John Wick” and its action-centric acolytes). It’s fitting that “Over Your Dead Body” is thrilling, funny, deliberately gross, and all over the map in terms of its tone. While the uneven pacing and characterization is as much a feature as it is a bug, “Over Your Dead Body” has the spirit of entertainment in mind, despite often pulling its punches.

The central couple in “Over Your Dead Body” are a classically unhappy pair of unfulfilled creatives. Dan (Jason Segel) is an ambitious filmmaker who has been stuck making commercials that he has no passion for, and his wife Lisa (Samara Weaving) is an actress who can’t seem to get hired, even by her own husband. As their fights get nastier, Dan books a weekend getaway to a vacation cabin in the middle of a remote, isolated lakeside. It’s through a series of inventive flashbacks that Dan and Lisa are revealed to both have convinced separate plots to murder one another. However, their bloody feud is disrupted when the escaped criminals Todd (Keith Jardine), Allegra (Juliette Lewis), and Pete (Timothy Olyphant) invade their refuge with violent intentions of their own.

This is the type of premise that is built for escalation, and it’s to the credit of Taccone that “Over Your Dead Body” does not become haphazard beyond its initial setup. The violence gets goofier and the characters get more desperate, but the film is stuck within its contained environment, and does not needlessly complicate the characters’ intentions beyond a simple case of greed-induced sociopathy. That the film is almost exhausted at points because these goals aren’t instantly fulfilled is actually a mark in its favor, as it gets only more specific as it continues. In what is a deliberate inverse of the perceived immortality of characters in typical action and suspense films, the characters in “Over Your Dead Body” sustain horrific physical and emotional scars, which become an endurance test to withstand.

Taccone is clearly in his groove when “Over Your Dead Body” doubles back on itself to stretch out the story, poking holes in its characters’ plans and revealing their insecurities. However, the film begins as an anti-romantic-comedy in which Dan and Lisa are asked to be completely nasty to each other in a way that almost feels childish. There’s some great jabs that they get at one another, but rarely do their insults go beneath the surface. Even if the intention was to show that these are narcissists who ultimately belong together, the friction is too muted for a film that goes so hard in its visceral gore.

Although both characters aren’t quite as pitiless as their counterparts in the original film, Segel and Weaving are a fascinating duo because of their vastly different energies. While Segel has played some version of the lovable sad sack multiple times in the nearly two decades since “Forgetting Sarah Marshall,” he’s well-suited to play a sensitive, yet highly reaction buffoon who is either brave or stupid enough to always act on his emotions. Comparatively, Weaving makes for an interesting choice as a perturbed, cold figure who has a chip on her shoulder that she utilizes to justify her pessimism. The tension between the characters is intensified by the age gap (which the film smartly acknowledges), and the notion that their respective professional opportunities have curiously seemed to vanish at the same time.

That neither of their plans are particularly thought through is a gag that works well in some instances, but grinds the pacing to a halt when the new villains arrive and have to once again reset the plot. While the premise is reliant on the humor of seeing this radioactive couple having to work together, the most that Segel and Weaving do as a pair is trade half-hearted compliments; for the most part, the action is segmented into individual tasks. Todd, Allegra, and Pete all have distinctive enough personalities, but they’re definitely written to be “movie characters.” Even if “Over Your Dead Body” was always pitched as being set within a heightened universe, it is jarring to see such over-the-top antagonists proximate to central characters that are ostensibly more well-defined.

Yet, the friction of tone is something that Taccone has always pulled off with his work in the Lonely Island because their style of comedy is one where countless jokes are fired in a short amount of time, guaranteeing that at least some of them will hit. The defining joke of “Over Your Dead Body” is that these aren’t professional assassins, and the threat they pose is largely because they’re essentially masquerading as more accomplished career criminals. Of the trio, Todd is definitely the most underwritten because the role of the slightly dull, muscled henchman has become a caricature. While Olyphant knows how to chew scenery and make a meal out of any pop culture references, its Lewis who steals the film by identifying a very specific type of weirdo; even if its a character whose behavior seems erratic, Lewis has a sense of what drives her that results in a performance that is both intimidating and hilarious.

Ending on a high point does any film a tremendous amount of favors, and “Over Your Dead Body” succeeds in paying off off-handed comment and brief gags in its third act, making for a very fulfilling conclusion. Even if the characters are held at just enough distance that they’re not lionized, Taccone knows that he has two charismatic movie stars who viewers will end up rooting for, for better or worse. Taccone’s previous directorial work included “Hot Rod” and “Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping,” two comedies that have gone one to develop cult followings. While “Over Your Dead Body” may not have the same long-term sustainability, it’s strong enough for there to be excitement over whatever genre subversion Taccone is interested in doing next.