Though the English-language version of the title of Pedro Almodóvar’s “Amarga Navidad” is a direct, 1:1 translation (“Bitter Christmas”), it’s actually the French-language interpretation that will probably give you the strongest, most direct indication of what you’re in for with the Spaniard’s latest piece of detailed histrionics: “Autofiction.” While not quite as snappy as the original, the French marketing team nonetheless provided the most blatant possible understanding that the first film since Almodóvar’s middling switch to anglophone cinema is one which will bring him back to the cutting reflexivity that defined some of his best work.
This shouldn’t necessarily be taken to mean that “Bitter Christmas” is among (or frankly, even close to) Almodóvar’s best work—we can’t reasonably expect the man to top the melancholy Fellini-isms of “Pain and Glory,” now can we?—but that key approach divulged in the film’s French title certainly makes some of the director’s more rote tendencies appearing here easier to swallow, like a relaxant placed under your tongue in the midst of a panic attack. It takes a while to get there, but once that high kicks in, the Maestro of Melodrama’s languorous aims suddenly come into sharp focus.
The same can’t quite be said for Elsa (Bárbara Lennie), a former filmmaker-turned-commercial director who, after the death of her mother one year prior, now finds herself faced with a series of blistering migraines and shortnesses of breath which she eventually learns to be panic attacks. In desperate need of a break from her work, she retreats to the island getaway of Lanzarote with her best friend Patricia (Victoria Luengo, also marvelous in Cannes competition title “The Beloved”) and her young son, leaving behind her firefighter/stripper boyfriend Bonifacio (Patrick Crialdo) in Madrid.
As it turns out, Elsa and her entire existence are mere fabrications of filmmaker Raúl (Leonardo Sbaraglia), deep in the trenches of his latest script. The metafictional elements don’t end there, though, for as Elsa begins to find new creative inspiration on her retreat in the form of leeching off her friends’ personal lives and neglecting her love, Raúl appears to be on the same track himself, and while he’s clearly prepared for the blowback his characters might face in the midst of such shameless vampirism, the stunted filmmaker might not be quite as willing to accept this reality when faced with the same confrontations himself.
For the most part, “Bitter Christmas” registers as a functional-if-unremarkable addition to the director’s canon, laying on his usual penchant for lively colour, dripping sexual energy and measured characterization in service of a recuperation narrative that ostensibly succeeds by mere virtue of not utterly flailing, à la Almodóvar’s uncharacteristically lifeless “The Room Next Door.” But just as Raúl and Elsa begin to feel as if something in their own stories is missing to add that spark of life, it’s the confrontation of that reality that then gives “Bitter Christmas” its own needed spark.
In the growing tradition of Almodóvar self-inserts, both Elsa and Raúl constitute compellingly opposing poles that draw on the same magnetic force of kitschy theatrics. Sbaraglia is obviously the more directly identifiable of Pedro’s mini-Pedros in the vein of Antonio Banderas in “Pain and Glory,” complete with the trademark flowing white quaff of white hair atop that head swirling with all those goofy dramatic ideas.
On the other hand, Lennie marks a different but no less crucial piece of the Almodóvar identity by mere virtue of being a woman; from the very beginning, Pedro has found countless expressions of solidarity with the lifetime struggles of women at war with the inanity of patriarchy—and often forced to meet that inanity with their own dose of absurdity to match. To make his own self-insert into a lady, then, at the same time that he also presents a more traditional avatar, gives “Bitter Christmas” a more active sense of engagement with its auteurist layering intentions than just mere structural shuffling.
How does an artist reckon with their inspirations caused by the private misfortunes of those around them; where does “fiction” actually come into play? It’s a two-pronged question that Almodóvar is far from the first filmmaker to confront, but “Bitter Christmas” so organically interweaves its own narrative necessities with that of its characters’ fictional writing that the lines truly do begin to blur with a casual effortlessness that, by the time you start reworking the pieces in retrospect, becomes unsuspectingly gripping.
As Raúl’s longtime assistant Mónica (Aitana Sánchez-Gíjon) demands he remove the prickly epilogue from his script, she asserts him that it will result in a minor effort that will still find its fans among his following; as “Bitter Christmas” reaches its own dissecting epilogue, the reality that this film could only have reached its potential by keeping that finale intact becomes the final bow on this scrappy little gift for Pedro’s own longtime viewers.
