Two Pianos (2026) Movie Review: A scattered melodrama that never commits to its thematical elements

Share it

Music is at the heart of Arnaud Desplechin’s “Two Pianos,” and yet, the rhythm with which the film moves slowly makes the beats and notes feel like an elusive, far-reaching element. The long-standing tradition of infidelity as the most important part in French cinema and its occasionally privileged, tortured characters thus comes up again as the central conflict. And although Desplechin tries his best to trudge the film with thematically rich ideas, the result is a scattered melodrama that never commits to any of them.

The story follows a renowned pianist named Mathias Vogler (François Civil), who returns to his hometown of Lyon in central France after teaching the piano for years in Japan. One look at him and you can understand that his nervousness about being in the town stems from something tragic. Although his mentor Elena Auden (Charlotte Rampling), who has summoned him, her prodigy, would make you feel like it’s one of those mentor-mentee things.

He is supposed to perform with Elena in a concert that puts him square in front of her with the orchestra giving them a helping hand – but soon, almost like tumbling rocks, the filmmaker reveals the real reason for his anxiety – he comes face to face with a former lover, Claude (Nadia Tereszkiewicz), and instantly faints. A whoosh of memories wound past him, and the tortured artist is almost instantly revealed. You see a literal shift in his persona – he almost shrugs into his body, starts drinking, and slowly starts to dissipate into the ether of misery.

It is also revealed that Claude, who is now an art historian, is married to one of Mathias’ close friends, Pierre Solal (Jeremy Lewin) – a local gallerist with whom he lost all connections after an encounter that changed all of their lives. Coming back allows Mathias to have a familiarity that he might have missed in his time in Japan. But it also brings out complicated connections with his past – not just with his personal relationship with Claude and Pierre, or with his professional relationship with Elena, but also a deeper connection with the city itself – he grows aggressively convinced that a boy he spotted in the local park is him from a time when he was young.

These seemingly unconnected coincidences somehow manage to drive filmmaker Desplechin’s ship forward, and to some extent, he is able to weave it with mastery and not allow it to sink. However, he also abandons key themes and characters at the drop of a hat for a takeaway about moving on. It feels so dire to be pleased with a constant stream of new threads convincingly thrown at you, but somehow none of them are able to be memorable. The great Charlotte Rampling is given a strong prospective role, but beyond serving as just another key note in Mathias miserable existence, she serves no real purpose.

It is disappointing because the melodrama is literally called “Two Pianos,” and it should be criminal to just abandon one of them to present a snapshot of a life in shambles that has no real pull beyond the surface-level anxieties of these privileged characters in turmoil. It is very difficult to understand and relate to Mathias, the tortured artist who desperately slips into persona non grata without any sort of real external force pushing him towards it.