6 Movies to Watch if You Liked ‘Our Little Secret’ on Netflix: Lindsay Lohan’s delightful return to the rom-com genre continues to charm audiences, with Netflix’s new Christmas outing, Our Little Secret offering a perfect blend of family drama, romance, and screwball comedy. Directed by Stephen Herek, the film brings Old Hollywood sensibilities to a modern Christmas story, complete with Lohan’s sharp charismatic screen presence and a story about reconciling with the past. The story follows Avery (played by Lohan), a sharp and successful business consultant, as she prepares for her first encounter with the wealthy and eccentric family of her boyfriend, Cam (Jon Rudnitsky), during a four-day Thanksgiving weekend. However, things take a turn when she discovers that Cam’s sister Cassie (Katie Baker) is also bringing home her boyfriend, Logan (Ian Harding)—Avery’s childhood best friend and ex-boyfriend, with whom she had a messy breakup a decade ago.
Set in a lavish Southern estate presided over by Cam’s demanding and hilariously passive-aggressive mother Erica (Kristin Chenoweth), the movie weaves a series of wacky situations, emotional confrontations, and nostalgic reflections as Avery and Logan navigate their unresolved past amidst the high-stakes expectations of their respective partners. If you loved the hilariously chaotic tale of family and romance in Our Little Secret, here are 6 other movies that like the Lohan starter deliver a similar vibe, whether it’s through dysfunctional family gatherings, holiday hijinks, or rekindled romances.
1. The Family Stone (2005)
The Family Stone follows Meredith (Sarah Jessica Parker), a tightly wound businesswoman, as she spends Christmas with her boyfriend Everett’s eccentric family. Chaos ensues when she struggles to connect with his free-spirited relatives, leading to plenty of misunderstandings, family drama, and unexpected romances.
Much like Our Little Secret, The Family Stone is one of those movies that combines holiday warmth with family dysfunction and romantic entanglements. Both films showcase the challenges of meeting a partner’s family during the holidays, with laugh-out-loud moments and poignant explorations of grief and love. If you appreciated Lohan’s character navigating a weekend with an ultra-rich, high-strung family, you’ll enjoy this heartfelt ensemble dramedy.
2. Happiest Season (2020)
Clea DuVall’s Happiest Season is a refreshing queer rom-com that tells the story of Abby (Kristen Stewart), who plans to propose to her girlfriend Harper (Mackenzie Davis) during Christmas at her conservative family’s home. However, things spiral out of control when Abby learns Harper hasn’t come out to her family yet.
Both films share a holiday backdrop where secrets, misunderstandings, and family dynamics create comedic and emotional conflicts. Like Avery in Our Little Secret, Abby must navigate a tricky social setting while balancing her emotions and intentions, making Happiest Season a perfect follow-up watch.
Also Read – The 22 Best Hulu Original Films, Ranked
3. She’s All That (1999)
This iconic teen rom-com centers on Zack (Freddie Prinze Jr.), a popular high school senior who, after being dumped by his girlfriend Taylor Vaughan (Jodi Lyn O’Keefe), makes a bet with his friends. They challenge him to transform any girl in school into the next prom queen. Zack confidently picks Laney Boggs (Rachael Leigh Cook), a shy, artsy, and socially awkward girl who is often overlooked by her peers. As Zack gets to know Laney, he helps her break out of her shell, and in the process, he begins to see her for who she truly is—a passionate and intelligent young woman. Meanwhile, Laney challenges Zack’s shallow view of popularity and relationships.
She’s All That echoes Our Little Secret in its themes of reconnecting with someone from your past and seeing them in a new light. While Our Little Secret is set during the holidays, both films showcase the magic of second chances and unexpected romance.
4. Anyone But You (2023)
Anyone But You revolves around Bea (Sydney Sweeney) and Ben (Glen Powell), who appear to be a perfect couple after a sizzling first date. However, something happens that cools their chemistry drastically. The two find themselves unexpectedly reunited at a destination wedding in Australia, where they decide to fake being a couple for the sake of appearances.. Their fake relationship soon blurs the lines between pretense and real feelings, leading to hilarious misunderstandings and tender moments.
Much like Avery and Logan in Our Little Secret, the protagonists of Anyone But You are former flames forced to confront their unresolved feelings in an unusual setting. The comedic tone, sizzling chemistry, and focus on rekindled love make it a great companion film.
5. An Unexpected Christmas (2021)
You can find a dozen movies like Our Little Secret on the Hallmark channel but the charming An Unexpected Chritmas is the one that comes to mind. The TV movie follows Jamie (Tyler Hynes) who convinces his ex-girlfriend Emily (Bethany Joy Lenz) to pose as his girlfriend during a family Christmas celebration. As the weekend unfolds, old feelings resurface, leading to heartwarming and awkward situations.
The premise of exes pretending to get along for the sake of family mirrors the dynamics in Our Little Secret making it a part of this movies like list. Both films strike a balance between humor and heart, using the holiday setting to heighten emotional stakes and deliver satisfying romantic payoffs.
6. EXmas (2023)
EXmas is a riotous Christmas comedy about two exes, Graham (Robbie Amell) and Ali (Leighton Meester). The story begins when Graham unexpectedly returns home for Christmas, only to find his family hosting Ali as an invited guest for the holidays. This awkward reunion sparks a competitive battle between the two exes, each trying to outdo the other to win over the family and decide who gets to stay through Christmas Day. With their new partners in tow, tensions run high, leading to a series of misadventures and hilarious reconciliations.
Similar to Our Little Secret, EXmas thrives on the tension between former lovers forced into proximity during the holidays. The comedic scenarios and emotional undercurrents make it a must-watch for fans of screwball holiday rom-coms.
