Your Honor (Season 2) Episode 4 Recap & Ending Explained: Much of Your Honor’s strength lies on the shoulders of its impeccable lead performance by Bryan Cranston. While the drama is tense enough to keep us hooked, his performance adds layers to our understanding of the character dynamics. Although his character initially emerged from prison as a damaged man, he is developing into a complex person who is navigating a number of challenging emotions through his performance.
Your Honor (Season 2), Episode 4 Recap:
Directed by Darren Grant, Joey Hartstone has written ‘Part Fourteen’. It follows the aftermath of Michael (Bryan Cranston) and Jimmy (Michael Stuhlbarg) meeting at Fia’s (Lilli Kay) hotel room. For the first time, Michael and Jimmy acknowledge the existence of Fia’s baby together. After that shocking incident, Frankie drives them in the same car. During that time, Michael tries not to show the terror he feels on his face. The car stops next to the place of Michael’s mother-in-law.
It makes Michael wonder how much Jimmy knows about him. He asks Jimmy how he knew that he (Michael) was staying there. In his usual fashion, Jimmy does not answer the query but diverts it to another topic. He invites Michael to the celebration of his 50th birthday. However, there’s one catch. He asks Michael also to bring his best friend – Charlie (Isiah Whitlock Jr.), with him. Michael had promised Charlie that he would keep him out of trouble now that he was the mayor of their town. So that puts him in an internal conflict. While Michael is scared of getting closer to the Baxter family, Olivia (Rosie Perez) is delighted by that since it means that her plan is working out well.
Trey (Germaine Brooks), who is in prison for his argument with Lil Mo (Keith Machekanyanga), calls Sheila to help him get bail. She keeps asking what they did to get arrested, and he refuses to clarify the particular details. Then, Lil Mo calls Eugene (Benjamin Flores Jr.) to ensure he has the cash bag. He threatens this young kid to keep it safe until he gets out of prison. Afterward, Sheila asks Eugene whether he was with these two when their argument happened. But she keeps seeing him as an innocent kid.
Right after that, Roderick (Mike Seal) shows up at her doorstep, asking for her son, Trey. She mentions that he hasn’t lived there for years. He notices Eugene holding a bag and invites himself to inspect what is inside. Since the bag does not have the money he is looking for, he decides to leave. Back in New Orleans, Olivia tries to groom Michael in a presentable manner. She takes him to shop for a suit from a tailor. Despite being let down by his appearance, the tailor offers him a well-fitted suit.
Meanwhile, Monique (Andrene Ward-Hammond) tries getting in touch with Lil Mo but fails because Eugene has his phone and keeps cutting her calls. So, she calls Sheila to ask for his whereabouts. She senses worry in Monique’s voice and asks whether she is anxious about money or drugs. From what Sheila knows about her sister, she cares about these materialistic things more than people. For years, she kept her distance from Monique precisely for this reason so that her son won’t fall into the rabbit hole of drugs or crime. That’s why she tells Monique to stay away from her son.
Michael meets Charlie and asks him to tag along for a birthday party. At first, he takes it as a joke until he realizes that Michael is inviting him to Jimmy Baxter’s birthday bash. While he had specifically asked Michael to stay away from the Baxter family, he soon realized why Michael was doing this. He and Jimmy have a grandson together; Michael is planning to go there as an obligation. Still, Charlie does not accept his invitation right away.
Jimmy goes to meet Fia to invite her to his birthday party. He mentions that he has also invited Michael, knowing all well that she feels a kinship toward him. Meanwhile, Sheila goes to prison to get Lil Mo and Trey out of prison. She keeps reminding Lil Mo of the warning she gave him before – that he should not let her or her house get into any kind of trouble. She then asks about Roderick, who was snooping around at their house for a few hours. Lil Mo understands the seriousness of the matter and urges her to get him out so he can take care of Roderick.
Carlo (Jimi Stanton) flirts with the receptionist from their hotel, and Gina (Hope Davis) catches him in those moments. She reminds him not to settle for anyone emphasizing how the girl he is trying to impress belongs to a lower class. Meanwhile, she is concerned about the security of the party since all their family will be together, and when that happened the last time, things did not pan out well for them. Carlo tries to calm down her stress, and you sense a closer bond being built between them.
Meanwhile, Michael gets his new suit from Olivia delivered in a gift box. That’s when Fia shows up at his doorstep. During their casual conversation, he randomly asks whether he now looks like Saddam Hussein. That was a comment his tailor shared about his appearance, and it seemed to have bothered him. While Fia laughs at his strange question, she offers to cut his hair and make him more presentable. On the other hand, Monique gets a call from her contact in the local police – Rudy (Cullen Moss), who informs that Lil Mo was picked up with Trey due to a fight between them. She forces him to get him out at the earliest.
Later, Michael shows up at Jimmy’s birthday party with his newly groomed look. Jimmy gets taken aback for a moment since he was not used to seeing Michael like this for a while. When he walks up to Michael, Fia arrives next to him and praises his new look. Jimmy tries to act genially, seeing her daughter’s inclination toward Michael.
Gina notices Michael from a distance and asks Carlo about him. Then she goes to him with the intention of escorting him out. But Jimmy himself has invited Michael to this private function. She keeps threatening his life if he keeps getting closer to their family. She asks where he met Jimmy. That’s when Carlo jumps in and tells her about their meeting at Fia’s hotel room. Dispirited, Gina goes back to have drinks.
Meanwhile, Michael gets a call from Olivia, who keeps trying to use him as a pawn while endangering his life. He gets an inkling that she might be listening to him and starts looking for a hidden microphone in his attire. After a thorough search, he finally finds it in his shirt collar and takes it out.
Michael makes further attempts to make Charlie come to the celebration. He does not answer Michael’s texts but soon arrives at the function. They get together and awkwardly have a dialogue with each other. Seeing both of them present, Jimmy starts his main celebration and goes on to blow off the candles and cut the cake. Then during his speech, he announces ‘a new member of their family.’ Right when you assume it to be Rocco, he names Michael and calls him into the limelight.
Michael sees something evil brewing inside Jimmy’s mind but finds no other option but to comply with his demands. Right after, he also calls Charlie to join them. Charlie is hesitant at first but soon walks up toward the limelight. In this awkward situation, Jimmy also invites his father-in-law, Carmine Conti (Mark Margolis, aka Hector Salamanca from Breaking Bad), who sends shivers down their spines due to the reputation that precedes him.
Your Honor (Season 2), Episode 4 Ending Explained:
Monique’s men help Lil Mo get out of prison and then ask him about the money bag. He tries to get in touch with Eugene but fails at it. So, he returns to Sheila’s place to see if he is there. But he cannot find the money of the kid either. They call Monique to let her know about it. That’s exactly when Eugene shows up on her doorstep with the same bag.
Meanwhile, Frankie escorts Michael to speak with Jimmy at Baxter’s place. He takes this ex-judge to their basement and checks whether he has any weapons on him. He eventually sees a microphone under Michael’s shirt collar. After taking it out, he kicks Michael in the groin. Then Jimmy shows up now that Michael is clean. He is jealous of Michael getting closer to Fia than him as a father figure and filling that space. He also recounts Michael telling Carlo about Harry the hook and making him introspect his crimes.
Jimmy is curious about the circumstances surrounding Michael’s early release from prison. Michael manically explains that he wanted to commit suicide and did not want them to be responsible or connected with it. He urges Jimmy to kill him right then since he is already pointing his gun at Michael’s head. Jimmy takes this as an insult to his terror since he sees a man willingly coming to him to get executed. He takes the gun off of Michael’s head and notes that he won’t be Michael’s executioner. Michael is left alone in the abandoned basement.
If we look at the layers that Cranston presents through his performance, it seems like Michael is playing some sort of mind game. When confronted with death, he does not show any evident emotion to Jimmy. However, as soon as the gun is removed from his head, he lets out a gentle sigh of relief that will be missed in the blink of an eye. He is most likely feigning his submission to death as a part of a bigger plan of deception. After all, Jimmy is not the only person who lost his beloved son.
<<Previous Episode
Your Honor (Season 2 ), Episode 4 Links: IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes
Where to watch Your Honor
